I would put Wheated up there with all the pizza titans in NYC - it's that good! Always solid no matter what pie you get. The staff are all super friendly and knowledgeable. It does get pretty crowded so I always order for pick up. Now the bagels and biscuits - holy moly! So good how can the same spot make solid pizza and solid bagels?! A true NY unicorn!

The pizza is amazing. The whiskey selection is the best I've ever seen. Everyone who works there is very knowledgeable, helpful and fr

Lovely service at this hip spot near Prospect Park. I just got a Cesar salad to go and it was delicious. Excellent dressing! I would definitely go back to try the pies. It's super cute inside and the pizza I saw others eating looked great. Tiny place, I can see why it fills up so quickly, I was there early and it was already pretty crowded.

Amazing pizza place in Brooklyn. We had to make reservations beforehand as the place was packed by 530pm. We got a few different New Haven style pizzas. Of them, the vodka sauce and NY slice pizzas were the best. Service was excellent. The F.U.B.A.R cocktail was delicious. Overall great experience.

Quality pizza and when you're there definitely try the bacon. Service was good and friendly. It can get pretty full so try to go earlier. Ambiance is a bit cramped though as seating is limited. Also they're closed on Monday and Tuesdays. They have a well stocked bar and you can see them making the pizza. Overall a good experience and will def come back.

I finally got around to trying Wheated's weekend-only sourdough bagels. They are a little pricey but at the peak of freshness with a good chew and present a nice alternative to Terrace Bagels. The burnt scallion cream cheese was on point as well. They are serving Coffee Mob on weekend mornings, and they appeared to be doing a big business. Service was friendly, and pickup went smoothly.

I visited this establishment to place a takeout order. I ordered the Canarsie Pizza and while I waited I ordered a drink. The drink I ordered was called Horses Neck. It was very good and had the right amount of alcohol. The waiter was very nice. He offered me water while I waited for my pizza. The restaurant was very busy. It wasn't very noisy just crowded. All of the employees were very attentive. Once I received my order I paid and left. The pizza was really delicious. I'll definitely come back and dine in. I would like to try other pizzas on the menu. I may choose another night to go besides Friday because it was crowded that night.

Stayed with family in Brooklyn who told us it was a favorite. We all went for a last-minute Sunday reservation. Our host was wonderful about seating us. Drinks came out promptly and were all delicious. Two salads for the table were fresh and flavorful. Pizza was outstanding--we ordered a variety but I loved mine with roasted eggplant and garlic. I hope we can come back again. The atmosphere is warm and friendly, with excellent service. It was a welcome place on a cold, rainy night!

This place has everything I love about my Brooklyn neighborhood. Cozy charm, unexpected magnificence in a simple package, and just this genuine Brooklyn humanity. My sister and I shared a Williamsburg pizza subbed with vegan cheese and added vegan sausage. It was absolutely wonderful. The chewy yet crunchy crust had just the right amount of char on the edges. Great toppings and the sausage was really tasty - I *think* it was Field Roast sausage, or something similar. My favorite style because it has its own texture that isn't trying too hard to be meat. Great neighborhood atmosphere, quick yet casual and friendly service, and though the dining area and bar were both packed, it's an easy place to be and I can't wait to go back.

We got the vinegar hill pizza with bacon added and it was absolutely phenomenal--every bite was delicious and the crust was honestly chef's kiss! The meatballs with ricotta were also delicious and a really generous serving with fresh cheese shredded ontop! The service was great and very fast--5 stars there without a doubt. The drinks were where we lost a star here honestly--great ingredients and I wanted to love them but the cocktails were just a little on the sweeter side for my liking. If you like sweet though? Definitely a place for you! The restaurant itself is smaller without a HUGE amount of seating and they don't take reservations either. My advice? Get there when they open or after the dinner rush if you're wanting to sit down for a meal and you won't be disappointed. They fill up quick which is no surprise because they're one of the best slices I've had in the city! It's a can't miss place if you haven't tried it. These guys really know what they're doing when it comes to pizza and I will be back!